When homeowners run into financial pressure, a second mortgage is often mentioned as a possible solution. For some, it can be a useful short-term tool. For others, it may introduce unnecessary cost and complexity.
Understanding what a second mortgage is, how it works, and when it actually makes sense is essential before considering one.
What Is a Second Mortgage?
A second mortgage is an additional loan registered against a property that already has a first mortgage. As the name suggests, it sits behind the first mortgage in priority.
If the property were ever sold under distress, the first mortgage lender is repaid first. The second mortgage lender is repaid only after the first mortgage has been satisfied. Because of this increased risk, second mortgages typically come with higher interest rates and fees.
Why Homeowners Consider a Second Mortgage
Second mortgages are usually considered when refinancing the first mortgage is not practical or possible. Common reasons include:
- The first mortgage has a large prepayment penalty
- Income does not currently meet traditional lending guidelines
- The homeowner needs funds quickly
- Short-term cash-flow pressure exists
- A transitional solution is needed rather than a permanent refinance
In many cases, the homeowner has significant equity but does not fit neatly into a bank’s lending framework at that moment.
How Second Mortgages Differ from Refinancing
A full refinance replaces the existing mortgage with a new one. This often involves restarting the mortgage term and paying penalties if the existing mortgage is broken early.
A second mortgage, by contrast:
- Leaves the first mortgage untouched
- Avoids breaking the existing loan
- Is usually structured for a shorter term
- Is intended as a temporary solution
This flexibility is one reason second mortgages are sometimes used as a bridge.
Common Uses for Second Mortgages
Depending on the homeowner’s situation, a second mortgage may be used to:
- Consolidate high-interest debt
- Fund urgent expenses
- Cover short-term income gaps
- Support business or investment transitions
- Manage timing issues while preparing for a future refinance
The key is that the use should be purposeful and time-limited, not open-ended.
Types of Second Mortgage Lenders
Second mortgages are typically offered by non-traditional lenders rather than major banks.
Trust “B” Lenders (Also Known as Alternate Lenders)
“B” lenders, often referred to as alternate lenders, are typically established trust companies, many of which are federally regulated and operate with sizeable capital and long track records in Canada.
These lenders generally sit between traditional banks and private lenders. While they maintain institutional underwriting standards, they allow greater flexibility in areas where borrowers may not fully meet prime lending criteria.
“B” lenders are commonly used when:
- Income is non-traditional or difficult to document (for example, self-employed borrowers)
- Debt ratios fall outside prime lending limits
- The property type or usage does not fit bank guidelines
- Credit history is less than satisfactory, sometimes referred to as bruised credit
Mortgage terms with “B” lenders are often one to three years, with the expectation that the borrower may later transition to a prime lender once income stability, credit profile, or overall financial structure improves.
Private Lenders (including MICs)
Private lenders often focus more on the property and overall equity position than on traditional income ratios. These solutions are commonly used when timing or structure is the primary challenge.
A Mortgage Investment Corporation (MIC) is a pooled investment vehicle that lends money secured by real estate. Individual investors contribute capital to the MIC, and the MIC in turn provides mortgages to borrowers. MICs are regulated structures in Canada and are commonly used to fund short-term or transitional mortgages.
Private lenders and MICs typically place greater emphasis on:
- Property value
- Equity position
- Exit strategy
Because private lending involves higher risk, these mortgages are usually structured for shorter terms, most commonly one year.
In some situations, it may be possible to request an open term, which allows the mortgage to be repaid early without penalty. This can be helpful when the intention is to refinance, sell the property, or pay down the loan once a temporary issue is resolved.
Costs and Risks to Consider
Second mortgages can be helpful, but they are not inexpensive. Homeowners should understand:
- Interest rates are higher than first mortgages
- Fees can be meaningful
- Monthly payments increase total carrying costs
- Poor planning can lead to repeated renewals at high rates
Without a clear exit plan, a second mortgage can become a financial burden rather than a solution.
The Importance of an Exit Strategy
A second mortgage should always be taken with a clear plan for repayment or replacement. Common exit strategies include:
- Refinancing both mortgages into one loan later
- Paying down balances as income stabilizes
- Selling the property in an orderly way
- Improving credit or income documentation over time
Without an exit strategy, even a short-term solution can become problematic.
When a Second Mortgage May Make Sense
A second mortgage may be appropriate when:
- The homeowner understands the costs
- The need is short-term and specific
- Sufficient equity exists
- A realistic exit strategy is in place
It is generally not a long-term substitute for proper mortgage planning.
Final Thoughts
Second mortgages are neither inherently good nor bad. They are simply tools. Used thoughtfully, they can provide flexibility and breathing room. Used without structure, they can add unnecessary stress.
Homeowners benefit most when decisions are made with a full understanding of both the immediate relief and the long-term implications.
Considering a Second Mortgage?
Every homeowner’s situation is different. A second mortgage can be useful in the right circumstances — but only when the costs, timing, and exit strategy are clearly understood.
I help Ontario homeowners evaluate second-mortgage options carefully, so decisions are made with both short-term needs and long-term planning in mind.
Maurice Kwok, MBA CPA MA
Mortgage Broker | Ontario
Sherwood Mortgage Group | Licence #12176
Over three decades serving GTA and Ontario homeowners
📞 (416) 618-9312
📧 maurice@sherwoodmortgagegroup.com
🌐 https://mortgagemaurice.ca
If you’re considering a second mortgage, start with a conversation before committing to anything.
This image is commercially licensed to Maurice Kwok through Envato Elements for use on MortgageMaurice.ca.